The Ultimate 2025 Full-Size Pickup Truck Showdown: An Expert’s Deep Dive
After a decade navigating the ever-evolving landscape of American trucks, I can confidently say that the full-size pickup segment remains the heartland of innovation, utility, and sheer power. These aren’t just workhorses; they’ve transformed into sophisticated mobile command centers, luxury chariots, and adventure-ready machines. For 2025, the competition is fiercer than ever, with manufacturers pushing boundaries in perf
ormance, technology, and comfort. As an industry veteran, I’ve seen countless models come and go, but a select few consistently vie for the top spot. This year, we put three titans – the Ford F-150 Platinum, GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate, and the all-new 2025 Ram 1500 Tungsten – through their paces in the most comprehensive real-world challenge to date. Our goal: to identify the undisputed champion for your diverse needs, from jobsite grind to weekend escapes.
These trucks represent the pinnacle of light-duty pickup engineering, blending formidable capability with unexpected refinement. Each contender rolled into our evaluation boasting a price tag hovering around the $90,000 mark, indicating their premium positioning in the market. While their cost was comparable, their approach to power and luxury diverged significantly. The F-150 championed its innovative PowerBoost gas-electric hybrid system, showcasing Ford’s commitment to efficiency without sacrificing power. GMC brought its thunderous 6.2-liter V-8, a testament to traditional American muscle. And Ram unveiled its game-changing high-output Hurricane twin-turbocharged inline-six-cylinder engine, signaling a new era of performance.
Our evaluation wasn’t just about raw numbers; it was about real-world applicability. Our panel of seasoned automotive journalists — Managing Editor Joe Bruzek, Detroit Bureau Chief Aaron Bragman, and Road Test Editor Brian Normile — meticulously assessed every aspect. They drove each truck back-to-back on identical loops, dissecting handling dynamics, interior ergonomics, material quality, and the overall driving experience. But we didn’t stop there. We subjected these pickups to rigorous towing and payload tests, simulating arduous jobsite conditions and weekend adventuring. This included two 200-mile real-world fuel economy runs – one unladen and one with a substantial 20-foot travel trailer in tow. Acceleration and braking performance were precisely measured, both empty and with approximately 1,000 pounds of payload in the bed. Critical family considerations, such as child-safety seat fitment, were thoroughly evaluated, alongside the sophistication and value of each truck’s advanced safety and driver-assist systems.
After weeks of intensive testing and meticulous data aggregation, the scores were tallied. The results, as always, provided clear insights into what each truck truly brings to the table for the discerning buyer in 2025.
The Contenders and Their Performance Metrics: A Detailed Breakdown
2024 Ford F-150 Platinum, 848 points (out of a possible 1,295)
The 2025 Ford F-150 Platinum (representing the updated 2024 model year in our test) continues to be a formidable contender, especially for those prioritizing ingenious utility and cutting-edge work-tech. While it clinched several objective victories, its subjective scores highlighted areas where the competition pulled ahead, particularly in the realm of luxury and ride comfort.
Our Test Vehicle Specifications:
As-tested price: $87,625
Powertrain: 430-horsepower PowerBoost gas-electric hybrid system (twin-turbocharged 3.5-liter V-6 with 10-speed automatic transmission); four-wheel drive
0-60 mph (empty/with payload): 5.6 / 6.2 seconds
60-0 mph braking (empty/with payload): 135 / 141 feet
Observed fuel economy (unladen/towing): 23.3 mpg / 11.5 mpg
Curb weight: 6,020 pounds
Where the F-150 Platinum Shines:
Unrivaled Utility & Advanced Towing Technology: “The F-150’s towing ecosystem is simply revolutionary,” remarked Bragman. “Features like Pro Trailer Hitch Assist and Trailer Reverse Guidance are not gimmicks; they are genuine innovations that transform the towing experience, making it accessible even for novices.” The F-150’s integrated trailer backup system was lauded for its superior capability and intuitive operation compared to its rivals. This robust trailer management system delivers unparalleled towing confidence.
Pro Power Onboard Generator: Bruzek emphasized, “For anyone requiring mobile power, whether for a remote job site, recreational vehicle, or emergency backup, the 7.2-kilowatt Pro Power Onboard is a game-changer. It’s a true portable power solution that adds immense commercial truck utility.” This feature alone can justify the F-150 for many fleet managers and contractors.
Exceptional Visibility: The F-150’s clever design, particularly its window-sill cutouts and lower-mounted mirrors, provides an expansive field of view, making maneuvering this large truck significantly easier. Normile and Bragman both praised the low hood line and upright windshield for enhancing outward visibility, a crucial factor for both safety and driver comfort.
Intelligent In-Cabin Storage: “Ford understands what truck buyers need,” Normile noted. “The F-150 boasts the best combination of easily accessible cubbies, a large front storage bin, and cavernous under-seat storage, making it ideal for organizing tools, documents, or personal items.” This focus on organizational efficiency is a significant advantage.
Outstanding Fuel Economy (Unladen): The PowerBoost hybrid system delivered on its promise, achieving a class-leading 23.3 mpg on our unladen fuel-economy route, closely mirroring its EPA combined rating. This makes the F-150 an attractive option for those prioritizing fuel efficiency and reduced operating costs.
Superior Braking Performance (Unladen): The F-150 excelled in our empty braking tests, demonstrating strong, controlled stopping power.
Comprehensive Safety and Driver-Assist Tech: With a full suite of modern safety features and advanced driver-assist systems (ADAS), the F-150 provides a secure and less fatiguing driving experience. It tied for best in child-safety seat fitment, crucial for family truck buyers.
Areas for Improvement:
Comfort Compromises: A significant drawback was the universal dislike for the F-150’s front and rear seats. Bragman’s vivid description of an “atrociously uncomfortable” lump suggests a design flaw that could lead to fatigue on long journeys. For a premium trim, this is a notable oversight in luxury seating dynamics.
Interior Quality and Refinement: Despite its Platinum designation, the F-150’s interior failed to meet the luxury expectations set by its price point and competitors. “Everything feels and sounds cheap compared to the others,” Bragman lamented, pointing to a lack of premium materials and execution, impacting the perceived interior craftsmanship and resale value.
Subpar Ride and Handling: Bruzek described the ride as “jittery” and “uncontrollable” when empty, with a tendency for the rear end to skip. Normile also noted excessive fore-aft motions, which made both highway driving and towing less composed. This impacts driving dynamics and overall passenger comfort.
Mushy Brake-Pedal Feel: The F-150’s regenerative braking system, a characteristic of hybrids, resulted in a less confidence-inspiring pedal feel, especially noticeable and concerning during towing.
Lack of Cabin Serenity: Despite its hybrid powertrain, the F-150 was surprisingly the loudest in the test, with noticeable noise, vibration, and harshness (NVH) levels that detracted from its perceived refinement.
Ergonomic Peculiarities: Small, low-mounted climate control buttons were a source of frustration, impacting ease of use and user experience design.
2024 GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate, 971 points
The 2025 GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate (representing the 2024 model year) carved out its own niche, offering a compelling blend of traditional V-8 power, upscale aesthetics, and segment-leading cargo solutions. It impressed judges with its robust towing prowess and advanced cabin technology.
Our Test Vehicle Specifications:
As-tested price: $87,305
Powertrain: 420-hp, 6.2-liter V-8 with 10-speed automatic transmission; four-wheel drive
0-60 mph (empty/with payload): 6.2 / 7.0 seconds
60-0 mph braking (empty/with payload): 146 / 139 feet
Observed fuel economy (unladen/towing): 21.5 mpg / 11.0 mpg
Curb weight: 5,580 pounds
Where the Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate Excels:
Intuitive Vehicle User Interface: Normile praised the Sierra’s touchscreen for its superior graphics and usability, complemented by an excellent physical control layout below. Bruzek appreciated the tactile nature of the controls, emphasizing their ease of use and intuitive placement. This focus on ergonomic design and infotainment usability enhances the overall driver engagement.
Exceptional V-8 Towing Performance and Confidence: Bragman lauded the 6.2-liter V-8 for its “unflappable manners” and confidence-inspiring performance, even in challenging conditions. Bruzek highlighted the direct connection to the engine, providing immediate response and a reassuring sense of control. This makes the Sierra a strong contender for heavy-duty towing applications.
Class-Leading Cargo-Box Storage: The CarbonPro carbon-fiber composite cargo box offered the most generous width between the wheel wells and overall length in our test, maximizing cargo capacity and load management efficiency.
Superior Bed Access: The innovative MultiPro Tailgate, combined with standard bumper-step cutouts and power running boards that extend rearward for bed access, made the Sierra the easiest truck to load and unload. This focus on loading and unloading convenience streamlines workflow.
Advanced Super Cruise Hands-Free Driving: Bruzek heralded Super Cruise as the best hands-free system in the group, noting its exceptional ability to maintain lane centering even in high winds and its smooth automated lane changes. This advanced autonomous driving technology significantly reduces driver fatigue on long hauls.
Premium Interior Aesthetics: “The best Denali yet produced,” according to Bragman, the Sierra offers a cabin that feels genuinely expensive, with full-grain leather and open-pore wood trim, positioning it as a top choice for luxury truck buyers.
Strong Braking Feel (Towing): The Sierra demonstrated confident and responsive braking when towing, a crucial safety aspect.
Child-Safety Seat Fitment: The GMC tied with the Ford for strong child-safety seat fitment, although a floppy belt buckle was a minor concern.
Areas for Improvement:
Compromised Visibility: Normile described the Sierra as a “rolling bunker,” citing small side mirrors, a tall and long hood, and a small rear windscreen that made it the most challenging to see out of. This impacts situational awareness and maneuverability.
Limited In-Cabin Open Storage: While overall storage was available, Bruzek noted a lack of convenient open storage options in the cabin, impacting everyday accessibility.
Measured Acceleration Lag: Despite its powerful V-8, the Sierra was noticeably the slowest in acceleration tests, both empty and with payload. Normile pointed out that “the Sierra makes a lot of noise it can’t back up in terms of performance,” which might deter buyers seeking a more immediate power delivery for dynamic driving performance.
Inconsistent Google Built-In Voice Commands: Bragman experienced frustrating inconsistencies with the Google-based voice command system, highlighting potential limitations in voice recognition technology and real-time processing.
2025 Ram 1500 Tungsten, 1,059 points
The 2025 Ram 1500 Tungsten emerged as the undisputed champion, redefining what a light-duty pickup can be. Its blend of breathtaking luxury, refined powertrain, and superior ride quality truly set it apart, making it a compelling option for those seeking a premium, versatile vehicle that transcends traditional truck categories.
Our Test Vehicle Specifications:
As-tested price: $90,505
Powertrain: 540-hp, twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six-cylinder Hurricane engine with eight-speed automatic transmission; four-wheel drive
0-60 mph (empty/with payload): 4.8 / 5.3 seconds
60-0 mph braking (empty/with payload): 140 / 146 feet
Observed fuel economy (unladen/towing): 21.0 mpg / 10.6 mpg
Curb weight: 6,000 pounds
Where the Ram 1500 Tungsten Dominates:
Unparalleled Interior Quality and Luxury: “This is, without a doubt, a luxury interior that any luxury buyer would be satisfied with,” Bruzek declared. The Tungsten trim elevates the pickup cabin to an executive level, boasting exquisite materials, meticulous craftsmanship, and thoughtful details like door-mounted seat controls. It sets the benchmark for premium truck interiors and automotive luxury.
Supreme Front and Rear Seat Comfort: The Ram’s seating earned top scores across the board. Its ergonomically designed seats provide exceptional support and comfort, making long drives a pleasure for all occupants. This focus on long-haul comfort and passenger amenities is a key differentiator.
Revolutionary Powertrain Refinement and Acceleration: The high-output Hurricane twin-turbo inline-six engine is a marvel. Bruzek noted its “insanely quiet and refined” operation, likening it to a German luxury car engine. Bragman added that the only thing buyers might miss from the traditional Hemi is the V-8 rumble. Normile was particularly impressed with its blistering acceleration, achieving 0-60 mph in just 4.8 seconds empty, and still leading the pack with payload. This power plant offers an exceptional blend of performance engineering and acoustic refinement.
Class-Leading Ride Quality (with and without a trailer): The standard air suspension on the Tungsten trim delivers an “incredible” ride quality, gliding over bumps with minimal bounciness. Normile initially mistook its 22-inch wheels for smaller ones due to the smooth ride. This air suspension also aids ingress/egress convenience by lowering the truck. This superior suspension technology elevates the driving experience considerably.
Exceptional Handling: Despite its luxury focus, the Ram’s steering feel and handling were notably superior. Normile highlighted its communicative and accurate steering, with the air suspension effectively controlling body roll. This unexpected sporty handling in a luxury truck is a pleasant surprise.
Hushed Interior Serenity: The Ram’s cabin is remarkably quiet, effectively isolating occupants from road and engine noise. Bruzek noted the “stark difference” compared to the GMC and Ford, making it a sanctuary on wheels. This focus on cabin isolation enhances the premium experience.
Outstanding As-Tested Value: Despite being the most expensive, the Ram justified its price with exclusive features like dual wireless chargers, heated and ventilated rear seats, a multi-level heated steering wheel, and reclining rear seats. It offers a comprehensive package for luxury automotive value.
Innovative RamBox Storage System: Normile appreciated the convenience of the lockable and drainable RamBox storage compartments integrated into the bed sides, offering secure, accessible storage without needing to climb into the bed. This intelligent cargo management solution appeals to a specific user base.
Advanced Driver-Assist Technology: The Ram tied with the F-150 for leading driver-assist tech, providing a sophisticated and safe driving environment.
Areas for Improvement:
Suboptimal Vehicle User Interface: The Ram’s expansive portrait-style touchscreen proved polarizing. Normile found the icons difficult to press while driving, and too many critical controls were buried within the screen, including the trailer brake gain adjustment. The vertical orientation also hampered the backup camera display, relegating the view to a small portion of the screen. Significant glare issues further diminished visibility and digital user experience. Bruzek criticized the digitization of essential functions like heated seats and main navigation buttons.
Pervasive Electrical Glitches: Bragman noted a worrying pattern of electronic bugs, from freezing Apple CarPlay to issues with the driver’s window and problematic trailer backup tech. These reliability concerns with automotive electronics can be a major detractor.
Strained Powertrain When Towing: Despite its unladen prowess, the Hurricane engine felt the most strained during our towing test and was the least fuel-efficient when hauling a trailer. This suggests the towing performance doesn’t quite match its empty-truck capabilities.
Child-Safety Seat Fitment Challenges: Harder-to-use tether loops, non-removable head restraints, and floppy belt buckles were identified as issues, detracting from its family-friendliness in this specific area.
RamBox Space Compromise: While innovative, the RamBox system significantly encroaches on bed width, which could be a deal-breaker for users needing maximum conventional bed space. Bruzek highlighted this trade-off for cargo volume optimization.
Missing Luxury Feature: The absence of a power tilt/telescoping steering wheel in an otherwise lavish interior was a perplexing oversight for a vehicle at this luxury price point.
Which 2025 Full-Size Pickup Truck is Right for You?
The 2025 Ram 1500 Tungsten, with its class-leading luxury, refined Hurricane powertrain, and exceptional ride quality, ultimately swept our comparison, earning its place at the top. It delivers an executive-level experience that truly blurs the lines between a rugged utility vehicle and a high-end luxury sedan. For those seeking the pinnacle of comfort, power, and sophisticated design in a pickup, the Ram 1500 Tungsten unequivocally deserves your attention. Its innovative engine and plush interior make it a compelling choice for premium automotive buyers looking for a versatile luxury vehicle.
However, the second-place GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate and third-place Ford F-150 Platinum are by no means runners-up to dismiss. Each offers a distinct set of attributes that might make it the perfect fit for your specific demands.
If your daily grind involves frequent towing, hauling, and requires robust job site connectivity or mobile power generation, the 2025 Ford F-150 Platinum remains an incredibly appealing choice. Its groundbreaking Pro Power Onboard generator and intuitive towing technology are unmatched, offering tangible benefits for commercial applications and fleet productivity. For the tradesperson or outdoor enthusiast who leverages every ounce of utility, the F-150’s practicality and innovative work solutions are hard to beat.
For those who value the traditional V-8 engine performance, unmistakable rumble, and unwavering confidence during heavy towing operations, the 2025 GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate is a truck you absolutely must consider. Its superior bed access, expansive cargo box, and the industry-leading Super Cruise hands-free driving system cater to drivers seeking a blend of rugged capability, upscale features, and advanced driver assistance systems for long-distance comfort.
Ultimately, the best full-size pickup for you in 2025 hinges on your priorities. Do you prioritize unparalleled luxury and a silent, powerful ride? The Ram is your answer. Do you need the most advanced utility and innovative power solutions for the toughest jobs? The F-150 calls. Or perhaps you crave traditional V-8 grunt, unshakeable towing confidence, and a premium cabin without straying too far from convention? The Sierra awaits.
We invite you to delve deeper into these remarkable machines. Explore the detailed specifications, watch expert reviews, and, most importantly, experience them firsthand to discover which 2025 full-size pickup truck truly resonates with your lifestyle and operational needs. Your ultimate ride awaits.
Out-of-Control Teen Turns a Trespass Warning at Walmart into Jail Time
